John Harley

Even in a cemetery that is kept immaculately there is in the British Cemetery in Montevideo in Uruguay one grave that stands out. It is topped by a standing white angel and is a measure of the esteem, in which the man, Scotsman, whose remains it contains, is still held, more than eighty years after his death. That Uruguay, a country with a population barely half our own, staged and won the first World Cup, then the fourth would without him have been unlikely. That Brazil won it in 1958 and again in 1962 might not have been possible. Yet in his homeland, in Scotland, there is barely a thing even to mark his existence, never mind the extraordinary contribution he has made to South American and thus World football. There is no statue in Cathcart to match Busby's homage to Tommy Donohoe's contribution to Brazil's game.  

The player, the man in question is John Harley, El Yoni. He was born at Braehead in Cathcart, then a village now a suburb of Glasgow. Walk up from the Old Smiddy pub, cross the wee Snuff Mill Bridge and follow the road up to the first crossroads, look left and the houses to the right replaced the but and bens that stood there a century and a bit ago. Harley's birth was in 1886 and was seemingly not without problems. Census records show him in 1891 aged four as a patient in the Mount Florida Deaf and Dumb Institution. His Cathcart-born father, James, is by then a widower with four older children still at Braehead, working as an iron-turner/mechanical engineer, having previosly been a fruit-merchant in The Gorbals and before moving by 1901 to Holmhead Crescent still in Cathcart, another sister and John now back, he at fifteen working as a grocer's boy. The background seems to have been that James's wife, John's mother, Carmunnock-born Isabella, had died of bronchitis and heart-disease aged just forty-two again at Braehead in 1888. 

James Harley would die, it seems, in 1925. John Harley may well have returned home briefly on his death but in the meantime he had firstly trained as railway mechanic/draughtsman, probably at the Springburn works in Glasgow. It seems likely that he learned his football there. The area had several teams. And from there he then found work initially not in Scotland but on the British-, indeed Scottish-owned railways in Argentina. He seems to have first sailed aged just twenty for Bahia Blanca in 1906, returned home briefly and returned in 1907, this time to Buenos Aires.There, whilst working again for Bahía Blanca and North Western Railway and the Buenos Aires Western Railway, he played for the latter's team, Ferro Carril Oeste (FCO), which exists to this day in the country's second division. Alongside him was a James Buchanan, probably the same one, who had played for Cambuslang in defeat by Renton in the 1888 Scottish Cup Final and who in Montevideo had also turned out for the Central Uruguayan Railway Cricket (CURCC)club team. It was clearly looking for new talent. It would not take the Uruguayan title that year. And in a FCO-CURCC friendly played in BA Harley was spotted, head-hunted, made a job offer and in 1909 crossed the River Plate never to look back.    

Harley would work until retirement as a draughtsman for the Central Uruguayan Railway. He had also on arrival rapidly assumed the captaincy of its football team. And with that he began to introduced the way of play he knew, the passing game based but adapted for local conditions around him at centre-half, the Scottish, attacking centre-half. It proved a revelation, soon adopted by other clubs, and then the national team, of which he too became an integral part, in the process creating a distinctive "Uruguayan" style. For that he was lauded and continues to be so. In 1951, fully nine years before his passing, he was awarded a testimonial club match at Uruguay's national stadium. Forty thousand attended. By then he had married and had a family, himself integrating fully, son becoming a well-known Montevidean architect.        

However, John Harley has a further legacy. Although he was not there in 1916 at the first playing of the South American Championship, it took place in Argentina with the host country, Uruguay, Brazil and Chile represented. In the match between Uruguay and Chile the former was accused by the latter of including "Africans". Uruguay did include Black players, and would insist on doing so. Indeed one, Isabellino Gradin, the grandson of slaves, finished as the tournament's top scorer. But it had been John Harley, who had first integrated Black players into the Penarol team and therefore the Uruguayan game based on their talent not their colour. One, Juan Delgado, would even be groomed to replace the ageing Harley in the Penarol team. Thus in his adopted country not only Harley's style of play became the model but also his approach to race the norm, one which extended to rest of the continent. In 1916 Brazil could play Friedenreich. In 1958 it gave us Pele.

© Copyright. All rights reserved/Todos los derechos reservados.


Any use of material created by the SFHG for this web-site will be subject to an agreed donation or donations to an SFHG appeal/Cualquier uso del material creado por SFHG para este sitio web estará sujeto a una donación acordada o donaciones a una apelación de SFHG.

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.